How The National Association of Realtors (NAR) Settlement Changes Real Estate Commissions and Helps Buyers

Discover how the recent $418 million settlement by the National Association of Realtors (NAR) is transforming real estate commissions. Learn about the elimination of the 6% commission rule, new challenges for homebuyers, and what these changes mean for the future of real estate transactions. Stay informed on the evolving landscape of the housing market.

The real estate market is undergoing a significant transformation following the National Association of Realtors’ (NAR) landmark $418 million settlement. This agreement, which still requires final court approval, aims to resolve multiple lawsuits brought by home sellers regarding broker commissions. One of the most notable changes is the elimination of the rule that required home sellers to offer commissions to buyers’ agents, a practice that traditionally kept commission rates at 5-6% of the home’s sale price. This shift is expected to foster a more competitive and transparent market. However, it also raises concerns about buyers potentially losing representation if they must pay agents directly. The full impact of these changes will unfold as the market adjusts to the new rules, balancing the interests of consumers and real estate professionals.

Traditional Commission Structure

Traditionally, the commission structure in real estate transactions has involved home sellers paying a commission that is split between the seller’s agent and the buyer’s agent. These commissions typically range from 5% to 6% of the home’s sale price. Critics have long argued that this system inflates housing costs, especially as technology has made home buying more accessible online. The NAR’s policy required sellers to offer these commissions to buyers’ agents to list their homes on the Multiple Listing Service (MLS), which critics said kept commission rates artificially high.

Key Changes in the Settlement

The settlement brings a pivotal change: home sellers will no longer be required to offer commissions to buyers’ agents as a condition for listing on the MLS. This move is expected to foster a more competitive and transparent market. Buyers’ agents will now need to secure explicit agreements with their clients, clearly outlining service charges upfront. This change could significantly alter how agents are compensated and how buyers approach securing representation.

Benefits for Home Sellers

For home sellers, the elimination of mandatory commission offers to buyers’ agents means potentially lower transaction costs. Sellers can now negotiate commissions more freely, which could reduce their overall expenses in selling a home. This change is expected to make the selling process more cost-effective and attractive.

Potential Challenges for Home Buyers

While the changes are beneficial to sellers, they pose potential challenges for buyers. If buyers must pay agents directly, they may face difficulties in securing representation. The added cost could deter some buyers from hiring agents, potentially leading to a loss of professional guidance in the home buying process. This shift necessitates a careful evaluation by buyers of the services they receive and the fees they pay.

Balancing Interests

The settlement aims to balance the interests of both consumers and real estate professionals while addressing longstanding concerns about commission practices. The full impact of these changes will become clearer as they are implemented and as the market adjusts to the new rules. Both buyers and sellers will need to navigate this evolving landscape carefully to maximize their benefits.

Questions for Homebuyers

For homebuyers, several important questions arise from these changes:

  1. How will the elimination of mandatory commission offers for buyers’ agents affect my home buying costs?
    • Understanding the potential for reduced commission expenses can help buyers budget more effectively.
  2. What new responsibilities will I have in securing representation with a buyer’s agent?
    • Knowing the need for explicit buyer representation agreements can prepare buyers for additional steps and possible upfront costs.
  3. Will the changes in commission structure impact the level of service I receive from my buyer’s agent?
    • This question addresses concerns about whether agents will still provide comprehensive services under the new compensation model.
  4. How can I ensure that I am getting fair representation and value for the fees I pay to my buyer’s agent?
    • Guidance on evaluating agent services and fees can help buyers make informed decisions.
  5. Are there any states or regions where these changes might be implemented differently?
    • Local variations in how the settlement is applied could affect buyers differently depending on their location.

Questions for Realtors

Realtors also face several important considerations:

  1. How should I adjust my business model to adapt to the new commission structure?
    • Strategic insights on adapting to a more competitive and transparent market can help realtors stay successful.
  2. What steps should I take to clearly communicate the new fee structures to my clients?
    • Effective communication strategies will be crucial in explaining the changes and maintaining client trust.
  3. How will the new requirement for explicit buyer representation agreements change my interactions with clients?
    • Understanding the implications of these agreements can help realtors prepare for new administrative processes.
  4. What are the best practices for negotiating compensation directly with clients off-MLS?
    • Learning negotiation techniques and strategies can help realtors navigate the new landscape effectively.
  5. What impact might these changes have on the overall housing market and my potential earnings?
    • Insight into market dynamics and earnings potential will help realtors plan for their financial futures.

Looking Ahead

As the real estate market adapts to these changes, both buyers and sellers will need to stay informed and proactive. Buyers must carefully evaluate the value they receive from their agents and negotiate fair compensation. Sellers, on the other hand, should take advantage of the new flexibility in commission negotiations to reduce their costs.

Realtors will need to adapt their business models to remain competitive and ensure they provide clear, transparent service agreements to their clients. This transitional period will be crucial for real estate professionals to demonstrate their value and maintain client trust.


The NAR’s landmark settlement marks a significant shift in the real estate industry. By eliminating mandatory commission offers for buyers’ agents, the market is poised to become more competitive and transparent. While this change benefits sellers by reducing their costs, it presents new challenges for buyers who must navigate the additional responsibility of securing representation and negotiating fees.

Both consumers and real estate professionals will need to adapt to this new landscape. By asking the right questions and staying informed, homebuyers and realtors can successfully navigate these changes and make informed decisions that benefit their interests.

As the market adjusts to these new rules, the real estate industry will continue to evolve. The true impact of these changes will unfold over time, highlighting the need for ongoing education and adaptation in the ever-changing real estate market.

Recent Posts